Can't Trust Your Advisor? How to Switch to a Fiduciary
- Fiduciary Financial Advise
- Jan 9
- 11 min read
If you think your financial advisor isn’t prioritizing your best interests, switching to a fiduciary advisor can help protect your financial future. Fiduciary advisors are legally required to act in your best interest, unlike non-fiduciaries who may recommend products for commissions. Here’s what you need to know:
Fiduciary vs. Non-Fiduciary: Fiduciaries must always prioritize your financial goals, while non-fiduciaries follow a looser "suitability" standard.
Red Flags: Poor communication, high-pressure sales tactics, and unclear fee structures are signs your advisor may not be acting in your favor.
Fee-Only Advisors: Fiduciaries often operate on a fee-only model, charging flat fees, hourly rates ($150–$300/hour), or a percentage of assets (around 1% for $1M portfolios).
Steps to Switch: Review your current advisor agreement, research fiduciary advisors, and prepare your financial records for a smooth transition.
Switching to a fiduciary advisor ensures transparency, unbiased advice, and alignment with your goals. Use tools like FINRA BrokerCheck or our financial advisor database to find a qualified professional who puts your interests first.
Signs Your Current Advisor May Not Have Your Best Interests in Mind
Spotting warning signs early can save you both money and unnecessary stress. Unfortunately, some financial advisors may prioritize their own earnings over your financial success. Certain behaviors can reveal when their incentives might not align with yours.
Red Flags to Watch For
One of the first warning signs is poor communication. Patricia Jennerjohn, a Certified Financial Planner, highlights this issue:
If you're not calling because you don't think your concerns are important, or you feel they're too busy to address your concerns, those are big red flags [7].
You should always feel comfortable reaching out about your financial concerns. If you feel hesitant or ignored, it’s time to question the relationship.
Another concerning behavior is a transactional focus. Jennerjohn explains:
Another red flag: You only hear from your advisor when they want to execute a buy or sell order on your portfolio. That may be a sign your advisor is only interested in the fees they may pocket [7].
If your advisor only contacts you about trades and not about long-term strategies, it could indicate they’re more focused on commissions than your financial goals.
Be cautious of stagnant advice that doesn’t evolve with your needs. For example, if you’re shifting from building wealth to preparing for retirement and your advisor hasn’t adjusted your strategy, they’re not paying attention to your changing circumstances [7][8]. Similarly, advisors who dismiss your concerns or adopt a "trust me, I’m the expert" attitude undermine your right to understand your own finances [7][8].
High-pressure tactics are another major red flag. Promoting limited-time offers or "guaranteed" returns that don’t align with market realities often signals that the advisor is more focused on closing deals than creating a sustainable financial plan [5].
Understanding these behaviors is just one part of the equation. It’s equally important to examine how your advisor is compensated.
Understanding Fee Structures and Incentives
The way your advisor is paid can directly influence the advice they give. Fee-only advisors are compensated solely by the fees you pay, ensuring their interests align with yours [4]. On the other hand, commission-based advisors earn money by selling specific financial products, which can create incentives to recommend investments that benefit them more than you [6][4].
The difference between "fee-only" and "fee-based" advisors is also crucial. While the terms sound similar, fee-based advisors charge fees and earn commissions from product sales, introducing potential conflicts of interest [4][8].
To uncover these conflicts, ask direct questions like: "Do you receive commissions from product sales?" and "How do your fees influence the advice you provide?" [8]. Additionally, request a detailed breakdown of all costs for the year, including advisory fees and any investment-related expenses such as mutual fund expense ratios [4][8].
Checking Communication and Transparency
Misaligned incentives are problematic, but a lack of clear communication can be just as concerning. Transparency isn’t just about fees - it’s also about how advisors explain their recommendations. John Lau, a CPA and CFP, emphasizes:
You have the inalienable right to ask questions and get answers that you understand at every stage of your advisory relationship [8].
If your advisor provides vague explanations, uses excessive jargon, or makes you feel like your questions are inconvenient, they’re falling short of professional standards. This lack of clarity can prevent you from ensuring their actions align with your financial goals.
You can also verify your advisor’s background using regulatory tools. Check their name on FINRA's BrokerCheck or the SEC's Investment Advisor Public Disclosure website. These free resources can reveal any disciplinary actions, complaints, or regulatory violations [6][5]. A clean record is essential for trust.
Regular communication is another key aspect of a healthy advisor-client relationship. Best practices include quarterly investment reviews and a comprehensive annual check-in [6]. If your advisor only reaches out when they want to execute trades, they may see you as just another transaction rather than a valued client.
Steps to Switch to a Fee-Only Fiduciary Advisor
Switching to a fee-only fiduciary advisor may feel like a big step, but breaking it into three clear stages can make the process smoother.
Step 1: Review Your Current Advisor Agreement
Start by carefully examining your agreement with your current advisor. Look for termination clauses, required notice periods, potential transfer fees, and any tax implications, such as capital gains. It’s also a good idea to download and save all transaction histories, contracts, and performance reports for your records.
Ask your advisor for their SEC Form ADV. This document provides key details about their business practices, fees, and any disciplinary history, giving you a clearer picture of their operations.
Step 2: Research and Vet Fiduciary Advisors
Next, take time to find the right fiduciary advisor. Resources like the National Association of Personal Financial Advisors (NAPFA) database can help you locate fee-only fiduciary professionals [2][3]. Another option is Fiduciary Financial Advice’s curated list, which highlights advisors who adhere to strict fiduciary standards.
Make sure the advisor you’re considering commits to acting as a fiduciary for all client interactions [4]. Some advisors are dual-registered, meaning they may act as fiduciaries for certain services but apply a less rigorous suitability standard for others [9]. This distinction matters - of the approximately 308,937 financial advisors in the U.S., only about 5,000 (1.6%) qualify as full-time fiduciaries [9].
When reviewing potential advisors, watch for warning signs on their websites. Phrases like "Securities offered through", "Series 7", "Broker-dealer", or "Commission" may indicate they’re not exclusively fee-only [9]. Instead, look for designations like Certified Financial Planner (CFP), Chartered Financial Consultant (ChFC), or Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA), which suggest higher standards of professionalism [4].
During your initial meetings, request their Form ADV and a written fiduciary pledge to confirm their commitment to prioritizing your best interests across all accounts [9]. Ask about continuity planning to ensure your accounts will be managed smoothly if the advisor becomes unavailable due to illness or retirement [4]. Lastly, don’t shy away from negotiating fees before signing a new agreement [3].
Once you’ve found the right advisor, you’ll need to prepare for the transition.
Step 3: Gather Financial Records and Transfer Accounts
Organize your financial records, including details about income, expenses, debts, insurance policies, investment accounts, and tax or estate planning documents [11]. Having everything ready will help your new advisor get a full understanding of your financial situation.
When you’re ready to transfer your accounts, work closely with your new advisor to ensure a seamless transition. Take time to compare fee structures and confirm that they align with your financial goals. Keep in mind that conflicted advice and hidden fees cost Americans an estimated $17 billion every year [3]. Even a small reduction in fees - just 1% - could potentially add nearly a decade to your retirement savings [3].
How to Choose the Right Fiduciary Advisor
What to Look for in a Fiduciary Advisor
When selecting a fiduciary advisor, credentials are your first checkpoint. Look for professionals with recognized qualifications that reflect a commitment to ethical practices. For instance, Certified Financial Planners (CFPs) are required to act as fiduciaries in all financial advice scenarios, while Chartered Financial Analysts (CFAs) specialize in investment advice and portfolio management under strict ethical guidelines [1]. Registered Investment Advisors (RIAs) are also legally bound to follow the fiduciary standard, regulated by either the SEC or state authorities [1].
Another key point: confirm that the advisor operates on a fee-only basis, not fee-based. Fee-only advisors are compensated solely by client fees, avoiding conflicts of interest tied to commissions [4]. To verify credentials, use trusted regulatory tools like FINRA BrokerCheck, the CFP Board’s verification tool, or the SEC Investment Professional Online Tool [1]. Advisors registered with NAPFA (National Association of Personal Financial Advisors) undergo additional scrutiny, as membership requires a fee-only compensation model [2]. Resources such as Fiduciary Financial Advice’s curated lists can also help identify advisors adhering to fiduciary standards. Remember, fiduciaries must keep personal finances separate from client assets and disclose any potential conflicts upfront [1].
Once you’ve shortlisted potential advisors, use your initial meetings to confirm their credentials and understand their fee structures.
Questions to Ask During Initial Meetings
Start by asking, "Are you a fiduciary in every aspect of your service?" Request this commitment in writing to ensure your advisor is legally obligated to act in your best interest [4][13]. As Lillian M. Meyers, CFP®, CDFA®, EA, emphasizes:
The best way to know if your advisor is a fiduciary is to ask them! Have them put it in writing that they are acting in your best interest.
Next, dig into their compensation model. Questions like, "How do you charge for your services?" and "Do you receive commissions or third-party payments for recommended products?" can reveal potential conflicts. Ask for a clear estimate of your total annual costs, including management fees, trade fees, and underlying investment expense ratios [4]. For reference, hourly rates typically range from $150 to $300, and the average management fee for a $1 million portfolio under an Assets Under Management (AUM) model is approximately 1% [4].
Also, inquire about their investment philosophy and portfolio strategies. Look for an approach that’s straightforward and avoids overpromising returns - be wary of any guarantees far exceeding mid-single-digit percentages. Clarify whether the advisor offers comprehensive financial planning (covering estate and tax advice) or focuses mainly on portfolio management. Lastly, ask about their continuity plan: who will handle your account if they’re unavailable due to illness or other reasons [4].
This complete list of 20 questions to ask a financial advisor will help you better vet any advisor you might work with.
Fiduciary vs. Commission-Based Models
Understanding the differences between fiduciary and commission-based advisors can make your decision clearer:
Feature | Fiduciary Advisor | Commission-Based Advisor |
Legal Standard | Must prioritize the client’s best interests | Only required to ensure recommendations are suitable |
Compensation | Fee-only (hourly, flat fee, or percentage of assets) | Earns commissions from product sales |
Conflict of Interest | Legally required to disclose and minimize conflicts | May face commission-driven incentives |
Transparency | Clearly defined fees | Costs often embedded in product charges |
Asset Separation | Personal funds must be kept separate from client assets | Not always required |
Fiduciary advisors provide greater transparency and are legally obligated to put your needs first. In contrast, commission-based advisors might recommend products that benefit them more than you. Choosing a fiduciary ensures a higher level of protection and alignment with your financial goals.
Conclusion: Taking Control of Your Financial Future
Key Takeaways
Switching to a fiduciary advisor can help you establish a relationship built on legal accountability and transparency. Be mindful of warning signs like vague fee structures, high-pressure sales tactics, or unclear answers about fiduciary status. These could indicate your current advisor is more focused on earning commissions than on your financial health.
Making the switch doesn’t have to be complicated. Start by reviewing your current advisor agreement for any termination fees. Then, research potential fiduciary advisors using tools like FINRA BrokerCheck or the SEC Investment Advisor Public Disclosure website. Ensure they operate on a fee-only basis before committing. During your initial meetings, ask direct questions like, "Are you a fiduciary at all times?" as Molly McCluskey suggests [6].
Fee-only fiduciaries provide unbiased advice without hidden commissions. They offer comprehensive financial planning, including tax and estate strategies, and their compensation aligns with your success - not sales quotas. By choosing a fiduciary, you ensure your advisor is legally required to act in your best interest, giving you more control over your financial future.
With these steps in mind, you’re ready to explore trusted resources to begin your transition.
Resources to Get Started
To take the next step, several tools can help you find the right fiduciary advisor. Start with NAPFA's Find an Advisor tool to locate fee-only fiduciary professionals [2]. The Certified Financial Fiduciary® (CFF) Directory also offers a vetted list of advisors committed to high ethical standards [10]. For a more detailed comparison, platforms like Indyfin let you evaluate advisors side-by-side, using over 100 data points, including client reviews and professional references [12].
You can also check Fiduciary Financial Advice’s curated list, which highlights fee-only advisors, removing much of the guesswork from your search. These resources often provide free advisor profiles and initial consultations, giving you a chance to find clarity and unbiased guidance. Start today - your financial future deserves an advisor who puts your best interests first.
FAQs
What’s the difference between fee-only and fee-based financial advisors?
Fee-only financial advisors are compensated solely by their clients, typically through methods like hourly rates, flat fees, or a percentage of the assets they manage. They do not receive commissions or other payments tied to specific financial products. This structure promotes transparency and minimizes potential conflicts of interest. Additionally, fee-only advisors are required to act as fiduciaries, meaning they are legally obligated to prioritize their clients' best interests.
In contrast, fee-based advisors earn a combination of client fees and commissions from selling financial products like insurance or investments. This dual payment model can sometimes lead to conflicts of interest, as their recommendations might be influenced by the commissions they receive. Because of this, fee-based arrangements can lack the same level of transparency and may not always adhere to fiduciary standards.
How can I be sure my financial advisor is a fiduciary?
To make sure your advisor is truly a fiduciary, start by asking them to provide a written commitment that they will always act in your best interest and disclose any potential conflicts of interest. This document serves as a crucial sign of their fiduciary responsibility.
Then, check their credentials and registrations. Look for certifications that align with fiduciary principles, like the Certified Financial Fiduciary® (CFF) designation. You can also verify their registration with regulatory organizations such as the SEC or FINRA using publicly accessible databases.
Lastly, ensure they operate under a fee-only compensation model. This means they’re paid directly by you, the client, and don’t earn commissions from selling financial products. This approach eliminates outside incentives, ensuring their advice is focused solely on your financial goals. By following these steps, you can trust that your advisor is committed to putting your interests first.
How can I smoothly transition to a fee-only fiduciary advisor?
Switching to a fee-only fiduciary advisor is a smart move to protect your financial well-being. Start by examining your current advisor agreement. Look for details about termination fees, transfer restrictions, or potential tax consequences. This will help you prepare for the switch without running into unexpected expenses.
Next, explore reliable resources like the NAPFA directory to find fiduciary advisors. These professionals are legally bound to prioritize your best interests. During your search, ask essential questions like Are you a fiduciary? and How are you compensated? Make sure they provide a written commitment to act solely in your interest and share a clear, upfront fee structure.
Once you’ve chosen an advisor, handle the transfer of your accounts with care. Whenever possible, opt for in-kind transfers to avoid unnecessary selling of investments, which could trigger taxable events. Keep all related documents, including the fiduciary agreement and fee disclosures, organized for future reference. By following these steps, you can transition smoothly while safeguarding your investments and staying aligned with your financial goals.
Comments